In the beginning

The term “economics” comes from the ancient Greek word oikonomia, which translates to “management of the household” (oikos meaning “house” and nomos meaning “law” or “management”). In ancient Greece, thinkers like Xenophon and Aristotle discussed economics in the context of managing household resources, including property, agriculture, and labor, to ensure the well-being of the family unit. This was a practical concept focused on efficiency and resource allocation within the home or estate, rather than the broader market-based systems we associate with economics today.

The word economics evolved from its original Greek meaning of “household management” (oikonomia) to a broader concept over centuries, with key shifts occurring as societies and intellectual thought developed. Here’s a concise overview of when and how this transformation happened:

Ancient Greece (4th–5th Century BCE): As you noted, oikonomia referred to managing household resources, as discussed by thinkers like Xenophon and Aristotle. It focused on practical matters like agriculture, trade within the estate, and family welfare, with some extension to city-state (polis) administration.

Medieval and Early Modern Periods (5th–17th Century): The concept remained tied to household or estate management in feudal Europe, but as commerce and trade grew, thinkers began applying similar principles to larger entities like manors or small states. The term wasn’t yet used for broader societal systems, but mercantilist ideas (1500s–1700s) started focusing on national wealth and trade, laying groundwork for a wider scope.

18th Century – Enlightenment and Classical Economics: The shift to a broader meaning took shape during the Enlightenment. In 1776, Adam Smith’s The Wealth of Nations marked a pivotal moment, redefining economics as the study of wealth creation, distribution, and consumption across societies. Smith and contemporaries like David Ricardo moved the focus from households to markets, trade, and national economies, emphasizing concepts like division of labor and free markets.

19th Century – Formalization of Economics: By the 1800s, economics solidified as a discipline studying societal resource allocation. Thinkers like John Stuart Mill and Karl Marx expanded its scope to include production, labor, and capital on a national and global scale. The term political economy was often used, reflecting its focus on state and societal systems.

Late 19th–Early 20th Century – Modern Economics: The marginalist revolution (1870s) and the work of economists like Alfred Marshall further abstracted economics into a science of human behavior, choices, and resource scarcity. Marshall’s 1890 book Principles of Economics popularized the term “economics” over “political economy,” cementing its modern, broad meaning as the study of how societies allocate scarce resources.

But let’s not forget about the distinction of political economy—

The term political economy played a crucial role in the evolution of the word economics from its original Greek meaning of “household management” (oikonomia) to its modern, broader sense. Here’s how political economy fits into the sequence, building on the earlier discussion:

Ancient Roots (4th–5th Century BCE): As mentioned, oikonomia in ancient Greece referred to household or estate management, with some application to city-state governance (e.g., Aristotle’s discussions of resource allocation in the polis). This laid the groundwork for thinking about resource management beyond the household, but the term political economy didn’t exist yet.

Medieval and Early Modern Periods (5th–17th Century): During this time, economic thought was still largely tied to household or feudal estate management, but as trade and mercantilism grew, scholars began applying resource management principles to larger entities like states. The term political economy emerged in the early 17th century, particularly with works like Antoine de Montchrestien’s 1615 Traicté de l’oeconomie politique, which explicitly used the term to describe the management of state resources and wealth. Here, “political” referred to the polis or state, extending oikonomia to national governance, trade, and wealth accumulation (e.g., mercantilist policies focused on state power and gold reserves).

18th Century – Enlightenment and Rise of Political Economy: The term political economy became prominent during the Enlightenment as thinkers like Adam Smith, David Hume, and the French Physiocrats (e.g., François Quesnay) analyzed wealth, trade, and production at a societal level. In 1776, Smith’s The Wealth of Nations used political economy to describe the study of how nations generate and distribute wealth, focusing on markets, labor, and trade policies. This marked a clear shift from household management to the broader study of economic systems influenced by government policies, laws, and institutions. Political economy was the dominant term for what we now call economics during this period.

19th Century – Peak and Transition of Political Economy: In the early 1800s, political economy was the standard term for the discipline, as seen in the works of David Ricardo, John Stuart Mill, and Karl Marx. It encompassed the study of production, distribution, and consumption, often with a focus on how political structures (e.g., class systems, government policies) shaped economic outcomes. For example, Marx’s critique of capitalism in Das Kapital (1867) was framed as a work of political economy, analyzing economic systems through the lens of power and class dynamics. However, by the mid-to-late 19th century, the term began to be seen as too narrow, as it emphasized political and social factors over emerging scientific approaches to resource allocation.

Late 19th–Early 20th Century – Shift to “Economics”: The marginalist revolution (1870s), led by economists like William Stanley Jevons, Carl Menger, and Léon Walras, shifted the focus to individual choices, marginal utility, and mathematical models of resource scarcity. Alfred Marshall’s Principles of Economics (1890) popularized the term economics as a more neutral, scientific label, dropping the “political” to emphasize the study of universal principles of resource allocation across societies. Political economy began to be seen as a subfield, focusing on the interplay of politics and economics (e.g., trade policies, labor laws), while economics became the broader discipline.

In summary, political economy emerged in the 17th century as an extension of oikonomia to state-level resource management, became the dominant term for economic thought in the 18th and early 19th centuries, and bridged the gap between household-focused economics and the modern, abstract science of economics. By the late 19th century, economics overtook political economy as the broader term, with political economy now often referring to a specific lens within economics that examines the role of political institutions and power in economic systems.

Is it politics? Is it the economy? Or is it some mix of the two?

Leave a comment